The beginning of October is officially (almost) here, and I cannot be happier about it. Bring on the sweater weather, PLEASE. With September almost outta here, I’m back with our top sellers from this past month. And, yes, this roundup is getting me even more excited for the heat to break, pretty autumn leaves, and pumpkins everywhere. Ahhh, so exciting. I hope you guys are looking forward to it, too.
My usual fall rant aside, let’s get into the top sellers. Naturally, the fall basics made the cut: cozy sweaters (looking at you, Quince + our Cashmere Guide 2026 contender), fresh denim, and, of course, Birkenstocks (Linzi just did her big guide for fall, woo!). But the surprises? A ridiculously stunning navy dress I’d 100% wear to a fall wedding, and party-ready ballet flats (because, why not?). Alright, keep scrolling for the rest.
1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19 | 20
1. Quince Bella Stretch Wide Leg Jeans
Where to Buy: Quince
I’m with Abby. Anything with “stretch” in the name is absolutely speaking to me. A bunch of washes to choose from, too.
Abby’s Note: These Quince ones have the word “stretch” in the name, soooo…
2. Faherty Stripe Sunwashed Organic Cotton Top
Where to Buy: Nordstrom (more sizes) | Faherty (more colors)
I cannot stop thinking about all the retro-y striped tees right now, and this one might just be my fave find so far. PS: this was one of our Discord top sellers — thank you to everyone who’s been over there chatting with us!!
Amy’s Note: Anyone else drooling over Faherty’s new releases? I want this plum berry sunwashed organic top (and like 5 other things).
3. Quince Mongolian Cashmere Oversized Crewneck Sweater
Where to Buy: Quince
A slightly oversized, cozy, slouchy sweater? That’s also cashmere and incredibly soft? 100% yes. Other colors available, too.
Shana’s Note: Spoiler: I’m 90% convinced that the oversized cashmere sweater I’m wearing (from Quince!!) is going to win the top spot in this year’s cashmere guide. We’ll see (but I’d snap it up now before it sells out).
4. Mother Denim Mid-Rise Tunnel Vision Sneak Jeans
Where to Buy: Nordstrom (petite) | FWRD | Revolve
Shana tried on a ton of jeans, and these were in her top picks, sooo I’m intrigued. Read Shana’s full review if ya want more info, here.
Shana’s Note: This was my other absolute favorite pair. In person, the wash is less ‘Mother Denim Blue’ and actually looks more like rigid denim (the light in the photo is making these look a tiny bit more blue, if I’m being picky). Rest assured, these jeans are made from a really soft, stretchy denim (40% lyocell, 1% elastane). I sized wayyyy up because I had almost completely given up on Mother Denim (their sizes are bananas), but it worked.
5. City Blues Trouser Track Pants
Where to Buy: Nordstrom | Dillard’s
Track pants have definitely been trending, but if you lean less casual or aren’t totally ready for a track pant? These trousers are the perfect stepping stone.
Abby’s Note: Affordable AND office worthy.
6. Damson Madder Dog Walker Long Sleeve T-shirt
Where to Buy: Nordstrom
Shana was right for this purchase. I obviously want it, too (those washed out tees will always get me).
Shana’s Note: Yes, I bought a walk-the-dog t-shirt. No regrets.
7. Athleta Tempo Mid Rise Wide Leg Track Pant
Where to Buy: Athleta
And if you are ready for more of a track-pant-vibe, these are really tempting me right now.
Shana’s Note: Not-tight workout pants? I’ve been lifting almost exclusively in these Adidas track pants (petites recently restocked!! I wear a medium petite) but my size sells out fast. I’m thinking of getting a similar pair from Athleta, especially since they’re 30% off right now.
8. SKIMS Cotton Poplin Pajamas
Where to Buy: SKIMS | Nordstrom (size L-XL, on sale)
Click through to see the other pics, Shana’s definitely right about these being oddly sexy (this picture/stance is just not showing that, haha).
Shana’s Note: I swear these menswear-style PJs are sexier than most…yes? (Because of the bagginess?)
9. Rouje X J.Crew Rêverie Dress
Where to Buy: J.Crew
A summer dress that works for fall is probably the easiest transitional piece that I think everyone should have in their wardrobes. This one in particular by J.Crew is great — the cap sleeves, bodice, print…so good.
Shana’s Note: This dress is so similar to Reformation dresses, but I found the sizing much more forgiving. Same cute French-girl vibes, but a stretchier fabric and more forgiving waist and bust area. It’s one of those pieces that’s easy to fall in love with (and really easy to wear). While I initially thought this dress was too summery, in person there’s something about it that vibes fall. So much so that I can style it up with corduroy and clogs, and it all works.
10. Birkenstock Boston Rivets Clog
Where to Buy: Nordstrom | Bloomies | Birkenstock | Evereve (black) | Free People (black + burgundy)
Forever convincing me that I need Birkenstocks in my life, Linzi. Especially this pair with the rivets…just takes it up a notch. For more info on these Birks and Linzi’s full review — read it, here.
Linzi’s Note: A modern and edgy-ish update to the beloved classic Birkenstock Bostons. I personally like the the taupe for my wardrobe, but the black ones are GORGEOUS and the rivets stand out even better on the black.
11. Birkenstock Buckley Clog
Where to Buy: Nordstrom | Birkenstock
Aaaand, another pair of Birks. These almost lean more loafer to me, so they read a little bit fancier.
Linzi’s Note: I’ve worn variations of the Birkenstock Buckley for years, and they’re still one of my most-worn fall Birkenstock styles. This classic clog is one of those pairs that will live in my closet forever.
12. Birkenstock Boston Big Buckle
Where to Buy: Nordstrom | Bloomies | Birkenstock
Of course, the classic Boston Birks are on the list. I’d wear it exactly like the pics above — chunky, knit socks + Linzi’s slightly cropped jeans.
Linzi’s Note: No surprises here…I pretty much love ALLLLLLL the “Big Buckle” Birkenstocks. The big buckle detailing elevates the classic Birkenstock Boston with a chic and polished vibe — while still maintaining Birkenstock’s beloved comfort features. So good!
13. Madewell The Perfect Vintage Wide-Leg Jean
Where to Buy: Madewell | Nordstrom (petite)
Another one of Shana’s fave pairs from her big try-on. Love the wash if I do say so myself.
Shana’s Note: I do have a couple of absolute favorites in this list, and Madewell’s Perfect Vintage Wide-Leg Jeans are one of them. Oddly enough, once you size up there’s nothing wide-leg about them, they’re a perfectly straight, everyday jean that are soft, comfy, and come in a ton of sizes and lengths. I appreciate that the butt is cute even when sizing up, and I have been wearing the heck outta these jeans.
14. Mother The 10-4 Trucker Hat
Where to Buy: Nordstrom | Mother
Because everyone needs a fun accessory. (Check out the buttons on the side, too).
Shana’s Note: Unreasonably obsessed with this hat. Kitchy and great.
15. Open Edit Twist Reversible Sweater
Where to Buy: Nordstrom
Okay, I LOVE that this is reversible. Two sweaters for the price of one. Comes in a bunch of colors, too.
Em’s Note: Just when I think I don’t need another sweater, this situation comes out to play.
16. Madewell Puff-Sleeve Sweatshirt Tee
Where to Buy: Nordstrom | Madewell | Zappos
Such a simple way to elevate a basic tee/crewneck. Picturing it with slouchy jeans and ballet flats.
Shana’s Note: Rachel Comey lookalike? This Madewell sweatshirt tee.
17. J.Crew Classic-fit Kind of Preppy Graphic Crewneck
Where to Buy: J.Crew
Shana has me thinking that maybe my style can lean preppy. Except I’d get this a bunch of sizes up.
Shana’s Note: Okay, it’s me: J.Crew’s ‘Kinda Preppy’ sweatshirt made me laugh out loud – it’s great. Fits TTS if you’re actually preppy, or size up one if you’re only kinda. 😉
18. J.Crew Rouje X J.Crew Skirt
Where to Buy: J.Crew
I mean…this print is so freaking cute. The lace detail really makes it even better.
Shana’s Note: I have been wearing the heck outta this J.Crew skirt (blue). With sneakers and oversized tees, hoodies, and sweaters.
19. Loeffler Randall Leonie Crystal Mesh Mary Jane Flat
Where to Buy: Nordstrom | Saks Fifth Ave | Bloomies
Besides needing a fun accessory, we all need at least one pair of party shoes, right? Except, I would absolutely be tempted to wear these daily with easy jeans and something cozy.
Shana’s Note: The only party shoes I could ever want ever ever ever: these.
20. STAUD Phare Silk Drape Midi-Dress
Where to Buy: Saks
Abby did an entire navy roundup (SO good), and she casually mentioned this gorgeous dress. The drape is everything.
See ya next month with more top sellers!
-Danielle