Reading “One Foot On The Ground” by Shanta Gokhale

“Rereading a work that was important to you when you were young is like lying on an analyst’s couch,” said author Vivian Gornick. I completely agree. Rereading Shanta Gokhale’s memoir One Foot on the Ground: A Life Told Through the Body (2019), I realized that things that didn’t appeal to me then as a 23-year-old appeal to me now as a married woman. At twenty-five, I avidly read and noted all the literary quotations (her allusion to Donne is outstanding) that she interspersed in her writings to bring clarity to experiences with the body—her own and those of others.

In my recent re-reading, what particularly stood out were her descriptions of marriage, child-rearing, and caregiving throughout her career as a teacher, author, editor, literary critic, and translator. I’m sure something else will stand out the next time I read it.

Gokhale’s frank and detached writing, characterized by the attitude of “let’s not persist at this, let’s roll on”, takes the reader through her progressive upbringing in Bombay in the 1950s, her time as a student in Bristol, her marriages, the eminent writers and art critics of Maharashtra with whom she befriends over time, and, above all, her career as a teacher, PR manager, author and translator – all told through the lens of her body. The chapters are titled “Breasts, Buttocks, and Lisp,” “The Nose,” “Menopause,” “Eyes,” “Fibroids,” and “The Arts.” Observing the world and marking some of the country’s important events through the female body provides rare, captivating insights, and this is precisely what sets the work apart. The body as a place and lens not only gives her writing a ready-made structure, but also ensures transparency. “We don’t talk openly about our sexual organs. We are horrified by nudity,” she writes.

Refusal to be the angel of the house

The feminist bluntness that runs through the text is evident right from the start, when she describes her encounter with a man who praises his daughter as a modest woman who never raised her eyes to look at a man. Gokhale claims that at a young age, twenty years before this incident, she and her sister grew up in a house where modernity reigned supreme – that they walked around the city with their eyes boldly raised, looking at everything, including men. I also noticed the lack of a sarcastic remark directed at the man and his daughter.

In another instance, she describes her father’s horror when she read The Female Eunuch. “To him, the word feminism was like an ugly toad that had hopped into the pretty garden that people had been building for centuries… I became a feminist, at least in theory, if not always in practice.” (In another case, the father, expressing his horror at the word feminism, also asks her why they are getting married at all: “Come and stay with us in our retirement home in Talegaon, teach at Pune University, read, write, forget marriage and babies,” he once told her.)

From the perspective of intersectional, multi-layered feminist theories and life experiences, I know that you cannot always commit a feminist act, even if you are a feminist. If you don’t take a feminist stance, you don’t automatically become a misogynist or a non-feminist. Sometimes deviating from a system or set of practices means you don’t have the institutional resources to support you. But writing a book that focuses on the transformations of the female body is a feminist act. And Gokhale speaks at length about each of these experiences.

For example, the chapter Menstruation is dedicated not only to the experience of menstruation, but also to the comfort of sanitary napkins over cloth pads. It also explains how she forced her mother to teach her why women menstruate using diagrams. One can’t help but be amazed at how openly she speaks about a topic that is still taboo in India.

In the next chapter, titled “Breasts, Buttocks, and a Lisp,” she talks about the experience of wearing a bra for the first time and comments on the ridiculousness of bra advertising (“I dreamed I had the world hanging on a string in my Maidenform bra,” she quotes one advert). The memoir is flooded with such sober, open conversations about taboo topics.

Gokhale’s openness, coupled with dry humor, about her marriages and blunders in life is astonishing. Her acts of remembrance reveal her rejection of being the “angel of the house”: the ideal mother and wife. At one point in her first marriage, she described herself as “bloodthirsty.” She also says that it is not easy being married to her, a person as principled as her. She brands her second marriage as a tryst with another “unsuitable man.” About her single life, she sums up: “I needed a room of my own to be the person I was. Rarely are women blessed with such blissful single existence. The pleasure is not just limited to having my own space, my own work table and my own bookshelves. It also extends to having my own cool bed. A body on its own, no movement it makes that awakens the thought of obsession in another. The independence of being yourself, completely in itself, is heavenly.”

From women find Time to write

Women finding time to write outside of housework has been talked about extensively by great writers. Virginia Woolf famously written that women need five hundred pounds a year and a locked door to write fiction and poetry. Nobel laureate Toni Morrison confirmed that she woke up at 4am before her sons woke up to write. How did Shanta Gokhale, a two-time winner of the Maharasthra State Government’s awards for her novels, find time for her “mental life” (as her mother described it) amidst housekeeping, numerous moves, caring for her husband and children, and various jobs?

She was also part of the Forum Against Rape formed in 1980 against the verdict in the Mathura rape case. She wrote scripts for plays and, as she put it, “sang women’s songs, danced women’s dances, and spoke and wrote about women.” At various points in the work, Gokhale speaks of having found the right material conditions – time and space – for writing. She writes, “The children behaved well and agreed to let me write whenever I wanted. Our understanding was that when I said I was not Aai but Shanta Gokhale, they should have a chat and not bother me.” In another instance of finding time to write alongside her corporate job as a PR manager, she writes: “I had managed to write my first novel, Rita Welinkar, on a tight schedule and the time available to me while married and working full-time. I let chapters write in my head while I took the bus to work, and then sat under a tree on the lawn at Glaxo at lunchtime, with my back to the main gate, to dissuade friends from saying hello, and to doodle quickly.” write down what I was thinking about on the bus.”

About Shanta Gokhale’s website

“One Foot on the Ground” is rich in lucid accounts of friendships, many with the doyens of Indian literature, some of whom become its “deus ex machina” (like the poet Nizzim Ezekiel): the person who brings unexpected solutions in difficult times. From Satyadev Dubey, the famous theater director and screenwriter, who encouraged her to try translation, to renowned playwright Vijay Tendulkar, who gently urged her to write a novel “for herself”, one sees a host of friends who saw the potential in her as a writer and pushed her in the right direction.

As I read the final chapter, “Boots for My Bunions,” a humorous account of her shopping at a shoe store for the right shoes for her aging feet, I wondered what Gokhale would say about aging gracefully. Obviously, she will not reject the term that is popular in the present. In her surgically precise language she could say: “Not my case. No, thank you.”

Looking back on a productive life, a life full of literary achievements, heartbreak and endurance, with meticulous distance and humor: this is what Gokhale does in her autobiography. Non-judgmental, clear writing of observations (But I feel like she refuses to use negative adjectives to describe people who deserve snarky remarks). Memoirs provide opportunities for the private self to negotiate a relationship with social space. They are also places of cultural memory. By reading Gokhale’s autobiography, one learns about how the narrator became the person she is, about the changing literary and cultural landscape of Maharashtra and also about the major changes that the city of Bombay underwent in the 20th century. One Foot on the Ground can be read for Gokhale’s impressive eye for detail, the unexpected sentences (“I’m particularly on the lookout for unfashionable shoes”) and for the paradoxical pleasure of reading “Pain,” tinged with razor-sharp wit.

One Foot on the Ground: A Life Told Through the Body is an autobiography by Indian writer, translator and cultural commentator Shanta Gokhale, published in 2019 by Speaking Tiger Books.